Please reload the page to update with the latest MLS information available.

Please reload the page to update with the latest MLS information available.

Please reload the page to update with the latest MLS information available.

Reload
 
Listing provided courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices Florida Network Realty- MLS# 260764MLS Provider

16 May StSt Augustine, FL 32084

Single Family · 4 Beds · 4 Full Baths · 4,495 Sq. ft. | 0.28 Acres
$1,495,000 Active

16 May St Overview

Time on Site:
136 days
Visits:
39

History & Romance abound! Step into this 1925 castle that dreams are made of. Designed and built by renowned sculptor Charles A. Pillar for his home and studio. The property is currently one of the area's most unique and beautiful homes, just minutes from the sands of Vilano Beach and Matanzas Inlet, and historic downtown St. Augustine. The castle boasts almost 5,000 sq ft of beautifully designed rooms, with recent updates to meet modern comfort standards. This 4-bedroom, 4-bath home lives large and is currently a residence and successful short-term rental. For generational living or an in-law suite, there is a separate entrance. This is the perfect home for family gatherings and entertaining. Come and live your dream in this turn key, well maintained fully furnished property Qualified buyers, Showings by appointment

Love this property?
Create a profile so you can receive updates on this property as soon as they happen!
View Map

16 May St Facts & Features

  • Type Single Family
  • Sq. ft. 4,495
  • Price/Sq.ft. $333
  • Lot 0.28 Acres

Details

General

Association/HOA

  • Association: No

Building Information

  • New Construction: No
  • Year Built: 1925

Location/Region

  • County Or Parish: St. Johns
  • MLS Area Major: 03
  • Subdivision Name: Nelmar Terrace

Tax Information

  • Tax Annual Amount: $17,758.15
  • Tax Year: 2025

General Information

  • Parcel Number: 154060-0000
  • Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
  • Property Type: RESIDENTIAL
  • Zoning: res

Interior

Beds/Baths

  • Bathrooms Full: 4
  • Bedrooms Total: 4

General Information

  • Entry Location: Ground Level
  • Living Area: 4495
  • Stories: 3

Exterior

Lot Information

  • Lot Size Acres: 0.28
  • Lot Size Area: N/A
  • Lot Size Dimensions: 12197

Waterfront/View

  • Waterfront: No

16 May St Neighborhood

Community

32084 (ST AUGUSTINE) Demographics

43
Median Age
699
Population Density (per sq. mile)
37%
College Educated
$54,519
Estimated Median Income
8,998
Estimated Total Home Owners
4,013
Estimated Total Renters
69% / 31%
Estimated Owner / Renter Divide
3
Estimated Average Household Size
Community data courtesy of LiveBy, Inc.

Schools

School data unavailable, School data courtesy of LiveBy, Inc. School ratings are based on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being the highest rating and 1 being the lowest rating.

16 May St Monthly Cost

$
$ %
%
$
$
Dylan Leitman
* All calculations are estimates and provided by Reliance Network, for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary. ** Assumes 6.50% APR, 20% down payment, and conventional 30-year fixed rate first mortgage. Rates cited are for instructional purposes only; current rates are subject to change at any time without notice. You should not make any decisions based simply on the information provided. Additional required amounts such as taxes, insurance, homeowner association dues, assessments, mortgage insurance premiums, flood insurance or other such required payments should also be considered. Contact your mortgage company for current rates and additional information. Any mortgage broker or insurance agent that may appear is independent and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or provided by the MLS.

16 May St Market Data

Based on the last 30 days in this zip code

$594,272
Average List Price
$353
Average Price per Square Foot
131
Properties Sold
116
Average Days on Market
597
Properties for Sale
Calculations provided by Reliance Network

16 May St History

Date Event Value Agent
6/15/2026Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS Price Reduction
$1,495,000 -3.5%
Bonne Jones
Listing Agent
3/25/2026Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS Price Reduction
$1,550,000 -1.0%
Bonne Jones
Listing Agent
2/14/2026Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS Added to Database
February 14, 2026
Bonne Jones
Listing Agent
12/19/2023Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS Status Change
Closed
Steve Markfeld
Listing Agent
Bonne Jones
Selling Agent
12/10/2023Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS Status Change
Conting_Accpt Backups
Steve Markfeld
Listing Agent